Fiber Cement Shake Vs Vinyl Shake Siding

See what bob vila says about vinyl siding vs fiber cement aka hardie board.

Fiber cement shake vs vinyl shake siding.

Choosing the right siding material for your home is a decision that s based on many factors from good looks to cost. On average homeowners across the us spend 3 5 sq ft. They also will add both charm and major curb. If you need to update your siding shake sidings are a great option.

Leading consumer focused publication when provia decided to expand its portfolio of home exterior products in 2009 provia s siding stood out as a leader in the vinyl siding and exterior cladding industry. When first designed and released fiber cement more closely mimicked natural or cedar shake shingles. Overall value for those of you keeping score at home according to the factors we listed vinyl would win in a landslide as the final score is 6 factors favor vinyl 2 favor fiber cement and a tie on one other factor. Homeadvisor s siding comparison guide explores the differences pros and cons of fiber cement and vinyl including information on james hardie s hardie board hardiplank fiber cement.

Both materials come in a variety of styles and colors. In the contest between fiber cement board siding such as hardieplank and vinyl siding almost all factors point to the side of fiber cement board except for one thing the cost. Fiber cement siding is molded to resemble stone wood lap boards cedar shingles wood shake siding logs and more. Its thicker than vinyl so up close it looks more like wood.

On vinyl shake siding including materials and installation. Likely when you think of shake siding it brings to mind either cedar shakes or fiber cement shakes. However vinyl siding can be made to very closely resemble the wood grain and naturally uneven look of traditional shingles. This process creates a more natural look.

Fiber cement you can achieve a beautiful plank siding look with both vinyl and fiber cement. The following guide will compare these two popular. Compare that to the 8 9 score that vinyl siding received and it is very clear that homeowners love their fiber cement siding more than homeowners who went with vinyl siding. Which is right for your home.

Each product can be designed to mimic cedar planks shingles or vertical.